01/24/24
By Rebecca Herman McBrayer
Please be sure to read our approach to Tasting Whiskey if you haven’t already. We were unable to acquire dried cranberries or pecans and decided to substitute raisins and peanuts. This made for an interesting tasting experience!
Rum? While visiting Punta Cana for a conference, Wayne and I quickly discovered that drinking bourbon was going to be a challenge because the offerings were incredibly limited. Therefore, we determined that we would drink the local favorite – Dominican Rum! Our bartender, Carlos, recommended Ron Barceló and Brugal.

Part 1: Brugal – Añejo, XV, and Extra Viejo

Distillery – Brugal, Dominican Republic
Proof – All are 37.5% alcohol, 65 proof
Mashbill – Unknown, but they use molasses from the Dominican Republic
>>Brugal Añejo (añejo indicates a premium aged, dark rum)
*Aging – up to five years in used bourbon barrels of American oak with a medium toast
*Color – bright, light amber
*Nose – light on the nose, sugarcane almost a honey, just a slight hint of chocolate
*Taste – buttery, light honey, brown sugar, slight caramel with white pepper on the back
*Tasted with a raisin – sweeter and the pepper is gone
*Tasted with a peanut – it brought brought out a warmth to the beginning and was more savory, less sweet
>>Brugal XV
*Aging – a blend of rums aged 3-8 years in white American oak casks and rums aged 2-3 years in ex Pedro Ximenez sherry casks
*Color – bright, light amber
*Nose – sweet, molasses or sugarcane
*Taste – caramel, honey, molasses, citrus, dried fruit, small hint of white pepper on the finish
*Tasted with a raisin – more flavors seem to be popping out honey molasses brown sugar. Much fruitier, a hint of chocolate.
*Tasted with a peanut – a bit of smokiness, enhanced the sugarcane, and still a hint of pepper on the finish
>>Brugal Extra Viejo (extra viejo, meaning extra old)
*Aging – the rums in the blend are aged from 3 to 8 years in ex-Bourbon casks
*Color – bright, deep amber
*Nose – deep aroma, molasses, slightly smoky, hint of spice, dried fruit, cocoa, more complex
*Taste – vanilla and caramel, smokiness, touch of honey, finishes with a hint of cinnamon and white pepper
*Tasted with a raisin – molasses forward but the smokiness and complexity is limited
*Tasted with a peanut – very pleasant, smooth, sweeteness returned.
Ranking – Extra Viejo, XV, Añejo
Part 2: Ron Barceló – Añejo and Gran Añejo

Distillery – Ron Barceló, Dominican Republic
Proof – Each are 37.5% alcohol, 65 proof
Mashbill – Unknown, but they use 100% pure sugarcane harvested from their own plantations
>>Barceló Añejo (añejo indicates a premium aged, dark rum)
*Aging – aged for 4 years in ex-Bourbon oak barrels
*Color – bright amber
*Nose – molasses sugar, caramel, light spice
*Taste -baking spices, light molasses and fruitiness, hint of white pepper on the back
*Tasted with a raisin – the raisin muted many of the flavors, but brought the molasses forward and added a stronger white pepper finish.
*Tasted with a peanut – there’s just not much flavor and it seems to be all peanut.
>>Barceló Gran Añejo (gran añejo indicates a premium extra aged, dark rum)
*Aging – aged for up to six years in ex-Bourbon oak barrels
*Color – amber
*Nose – caramel, butterscotch, cotton candy
*Taste – honey, sweetness caramel, cotton candy, and baking spices (nutmeg) on the finish.
*Tasted with a raisin – chocolate, vanilla, caramel
*Tasted with a peanut – caramel remains, hint of chocolate covered peanuts, caramel corn
Ranking – Gran Añejo, Añejo
Part 3: Ron Barceló – Imperial Onyx and Imperial

Distillery – Ron Barceló, Dominican Republic
Proof – Each are 40% alcohol, 80 proof
Mashbill – Unknown, but they use 100% pure sugarcane harvested from their own plantations
>>Barceló Imperial Onyx
*Aging – aged up to ten years in oak barrels with a high toast degree, subsequently filtered from real Onyx stones to obtain a rum with intense, deep notes and a unique character.
*Color – deep amber
*Nose – toasted brown sugar and a woodiness
*Taste – like it’s been finished in a different style barrel very similar to what we get in bourbon, hints of cherry, vanilla, coffee, and nuts.
*Tasted with a raisin – loses some of the complexity it does, but molasses comes forward
*Tasted with a peanut – it’s a little hot as it leans towards a cinnamon finish or perhaps allspice
>>Barceló Imperial
*Aging – aged for up to ten years in lightly toasted oak barrels
*Color – copper, amber
*Nose – honey, slight caramel or butteriness, and a very light baking spice
*Taste – spices, caramel, vanilla, dark brown sugar or toffee, oaky, slight hint of white pepper
*Tasted with a raisin – more peppery, caramel, fruity, good with the raisin.
*Tasted with a peanut – sweet, woody and a pepper finish.
Ranking – Imperial Onyx, Imperial
Comparison and Ranking of Top Tastings

*Nose – Imperial Onyx, Extra Viejo, Imperial, Gran Anejo
*Taste – Imperial Onyx, Extra Viejo, Imperial, Gran Anejo
Discussion – Wayne and I felt that they are all good. If we were to take only one home with us, it would be the Barceló Imperial Onyx. If we could add a second one, it would be the Brugal Extra Viejo … and that is exactly what we did … bought two to bring home.
Carlos and the other bartenders were awaiting our thoughts. We shared and they didn’t disagree. When we asked what they drink, they each said, without a doubt, the Brugal Extra Viejo as it is HALF the price of the Barceló Imperial Onyx, yet outstanding.
Wayne and I have never been lovers of rum; however, our Punta Cana visit help to bring a new appreciation of this spirit as well as hone in on what we prefer in a rum. These will be a great addition to our spirit collection and a very nice occasional drink.
Cheers,
Rebecca
Photos by Rebecca Herman McBrayer
NOTE: The spirits in this review were purchased by us. We were not compensated by the spirit producer for this review. This is simply our opinion based on what we tasted on this day. Please drink responsibly.









